Legal Opinion · Dissent

Martin v. Smith

Supreme Court of Arkansas

Decided June 20, 2019No. CV-18-813PublishedCited by 8 opinions

1DissentRobin F. Wynne, Justice

I would reverse the circuit court's grant of summary judgment to appellee on the basis of quasi-judicial immunity and remand for further proceedings. Therefore, I respectfully dissent.

On this record, appellee is not entitled to immunity. As the majority opinion recounts, Kenneth McFadden was released from the Arkansas State Hospital pursuant to a conditional release order and, ultimately, Gain was named "the responsible agency for monitoring [his] compliance to his prescribed medication and treatment regimen." Appellee, a psychiatrist, is the director of Gain. As such, he was McFadden's…

2Cases cited1 opinion

  1. Chambers v. SternSupreme Court of Arkansas · 1999

3Cited by8 opinions

  1. Victor Bernard Williams, M.D. v. Baptist Health D/B/A Baptist Health Medical CenterSupreme Court of Arkansas · 2020
  2. Dollar General Corporation; Dolgencorp, LLC, D/B/A Dollar General; Caddo Trading Co., Inc.; And Rodney Fagan and Judy Fagan v. Karen ElderSupreme Court of Arkansas · 2020
  3. DOLLAR GENERAL CORPORATION DOLGENCORP, LLC, D/B/A DOLLAR GENERAL CADDO TRADING CO., INC. AND RODNEY FAGAN AND JUDY FAGAN v. KAREN ELDERSupreme Court of Arkansas · 2020
  4. Tracy Will Vaughn v. State of ArkansasSupreme Court of Arkansas · 2020
  5. J. David John v. Martin T. Faitak, ph.D.Supreme Court of Arkansas · 2020

3 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API