Magical Cruise Co. v. Turk

I respectfully dissent because I do not believe that the petitioner, DCL, met its burden of establishing that the trial court departed from the essential requirements of the law by ordering production of the photographs in question after an in camera inspection thereof.

DCL is the defendant in a personal injury action. Respondent, Dorothy Turk, sued DCL alleging that she slipped and fell on the gangway as she was leaving the Disney Magic to go ashore at Disney’s island in the Bahamas. In her complaint, Turk alleged that, as a result of her fall, she suffered bodily injury and incurred medical…