Dannelly Enterprises, LLC v. Palm Beach Grading, Inc.

I concur in the holding of the main opinion that the trial court’s order compelling arbitration of the underlying dispute is due to be reversed. However, I respectfully dissent from the remand instruction that' the trial court “conduct a jury trial to determine whether Dannelly [Enterprises, LLC (‘Dannelly’),] and [Palm Beach Grading, Inc. (‘PBG’),] entered into PBG’s standard subcontract agreement.” 200 So.3d at 1170. As I have written before, I believe that predispute arbitration agreements are unenforceable under the Seventh Amendment to the United States Constitution. See American Bankers…