Reynolds v. Rowley

The judgment of the court was pronounced by

Rost, J.

This case was remanded by the late Supreme Court on several bills of exception, and is reported in 3 Rob. 201. On tho first trial in the court below, the jury gave a verdict in favor of the plaintiffs ; the defendants.failed in the attempt to have it set aside, and appealed. On the second trial, there was a verdict in favor of the defendants in reconvention, for one cent; the plaintiffs did not move for a new trial, and appealed.

After a careful examination of the evidence, we have come to the conclusion that we cannot affirm the judgment. 1.…