Walker v. Shell

— This action was prosecuted in the lower court by Josie Walker, plaintiff and respondent, against Carl Shell, W. T. Clinkenbeard, Luke Clinkenbeard, Morris Cook, A. Blomberg, and the unknown owners of the Jgafie, the Grangeville and the Columbus Placer Mining claims, so called, in the Elk City Mining District, Idaho county. A decree in favor of plaintiff and respondent was entered against Carl Shell, W. T. Clinkenbeard and Luke Clinkenbeard.

An appeal was taken from this decree by Carl Shell and W. T. Clinkenbeard only.

Respondent moves to dismiss this appeal because Luke Clinkenbeard was an…