Arnold v. Genzberger

It seems to me that, if we follow the law, the judgment cannot be sustained upon any conceivable theory.

1. As to the pleadings. By resort to extreme liberality it may be said that the complaint on its face states a cause of action against Meyer Genzberger, but the facts show that plaintiffs have no cause of action against him. To this all members of the court agree.

On the theory that the allegations respecting him are true, the complaint, liberally construed, may be held to state a cause of action against Gertrude Genzberger and Jennie G. Sternfels. The facts show plaintiffs have no cause of…