Yevoli v. Cristenfeld

Latham and Shapibo, JJ. (dissenting).

We believe that the county committee rules here under consideration are valid and we therefore dissent.

We agree that subdivision 2 of section 15 of the Election Law requires a party’s committee rules to be “ consistent ” with the Election Law, but, differing from the majority view, we are of the opinion that the rules are completely consistent with and do not violate any express provisions of that law or “ the general policy ” of subdivision 4 of section 137 and section 248 of the Election Law.

*158The majority, in a sweeping generalization, determines that the…