Weaver Piano Co., Inc. v. Curtis

(dissenting) : The plaintiff, Weaver Piano Company, Inc., commenced this action against the defendant, C. H. Curtis, in the Court of Common Pleas for Sumter County, October 11, 1929, for the recovery of certain personal property, consisting of seven pianos, alleged by the plaintiff to be its property. The defendant filed an answer, setting up several defenses and counterclaims, to which the plaintiff demurred. The demurrer was heard by his Honor, Judge William H. Grimball, April 5, 1930, who issued ah order dated April 12, 1930, sustaining the same. From the order sustaining the demurrer to…