Mackey v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.

SCHOTT, Judge.

This case arose out of an automobile accident which occurred at the intersection of St. Bernard Avenue and North Miro Street in New Orleans. Both drivers testified that the semaphore signals facing them were green at the time they entered the intersection and they both called independent witnesses who corroborated their testimony. In dismissing the consolidated suits of both drivers the trial judge stated that “it is impossible to say that either litigant has proved the correctness of his or her position by a preponderance of the evidence, or that his or her action did not…