Feliciano v. Escuela de Enfermeras de Puerto Rico and the Travelers

MR. Justice Ramírez Bages, with whom Mr. Justice Pérez Pimentel, Mr. Justice Blanco Lugo, and Mr. Justice Rigau concur, dissenting.

San Juan, Puerto Rico, May 19, 1967

I dissent from the majority opinion because I believe that the judgment in this case holding appellants liable for the injuries received by Mrs. Petra Feliciano as a result of a fall upon leaving the premises of Clínica Pila of Ponce should have been reversed. It was not established that (1) appellant, Escuela de Enfermeras de Puerto Rico, hereinafter designated as the Escuela had direct or implied knowledge of the fact that…