State v. Pace

We granted certiorari to review Petitioner’s (Pace) conviction for grand larceny as affirmed by the Court of Appeals.

We reverse.

FACTS

At trial, defense counsel asked Mr. Brown, a witness for the prosecution, “Do you have a criminal record?” The judge sus tained the prosecution’s objection, stating the question was “highly improper,” then sent the jury to its room.

In camera, the judge chastised defense counsel that such a broad question amounted to a “fishing expedition,” since counsel had no knowledge of any prior record against Mr. Brown. During his admonishment of counsel, the judge…