Legal Opinion · Dissent

McKay v. Lemly

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided April 25, 1949Published

1DissentMontgomery, J.

I am unable to agree with the construction of item two of the will arrived at in the majority opinion. The late and lamented Judge Albert H. Whitfield in Moss Point Lumber Co. v. Board of Supervisors, 89 Miss. 448, 42 So. 290, 317, 873, wrote: “The test is with me, and has always been, and always shall be, does the proposition, announced as law, square with sound principle and true reason? If so, I accept it, because it so squares; if not, no name,- however great, shall be permitted to lead me into false paths.”

In my humble judgment, the majority opinion marks a departure from the established…

2Cases cited7 opinions

  1. Cross v. O'CavanaghMississippi Supreme Court · 1945
  2. Moss Point Lumber Co. v. Harrison CountyMississippi Supreme Court · 1906
  3. Yeates v. BoxMississippi Supreme Court · 1945
  4. National Bank of Greece v. SavarikaMississippi Supreme Court · 1933
  5. Brumfield v. EnglesingMississippi Supreme Court · 1947

2 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API