State v. Illinois Central Railroad

Mr. Justice Hand,

specially concurring:

I concur in the opinion of Mr. Justice Carter (concurred in by Justices Cartwright and Dunn) except in so far as it holds that the semi-annual statements filed by the appellee prior to the year 1905 with the Governor are stated and settled accounts which are binding upon the appellant, and back of which the State cannot go, in the accounting held to be proper between the State and the railroad company, upon the remandment of this cause. As to that part of the opinion I do not concur but most respectfully dissent.

In my opinion the Governor, in “verifying…