California University of PA v. B. Schackner and Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

CONCURRING AND DISSENTING OPINION BY

JUDGE McCULLOUGH

The thoughtful and well-written majority recognizes, as did the Office of Open Records (OOR), that the affidavit and privilege log submitted by California. University of Pennsylvania (University) are insufficient to show that the withheld documents satisfy the .noncriminal investigation and predecisional deliberations exemptions from disclosure, and, also, fail to establish that they are protected under the attorney-client privilege. Nonetheless, the majority remands to the OOR to conduct in camera review- of Document Nos. 56-58, 119,…