ALAZAJUAN M. GRAY and CLIFTON SMITH v. UNITED STATES.

No witness ever identified Alazajuan Gray as one of the men who robbed Katherine Takai, and innumerable young black men on the Metro that day would have shared the traits that Mr. Gray himself shared only roughly with Ms. Takai’s description of the robbers. I am unwilling to conclude that the additional evidence that Mr. Gray was hanging out with—and causing trouble with—one of the other robbers an hour later and miles away from the Takai robbery and that Mr. Gray a week earlier committed a very different kind of robbery with this other robber renders the evidence sufficient to support his…