Matwyuk v. Johnson

OPINION

GORDON J. QUIST, District Judge.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. BaCKGRound.815

II. Discussion.816

A. Matwyuk’s Claims.817

1. The Court has Jurisdiction Over Matwyuk’s Request for Declaratory Relief.817

a. Standing.817

b. Mootness.819

c. Exercise of Declaratory Judgment Jurisdiction.820

2. Defendant Fildey is not Entitled to Qualified Immunity.820

a. Constitutional Violation.822

i. Government versus Private Speech .822

ii. Facial Challenge.824

iii. As Applied Challenge.826

b. Clearly Established.826

B. DeVarti’s Claims.828

III. CONCLUSION.830

Plaintiffs, Michael Matwyuk and David DeVarti, have sued Defendants,…