Hill v. Pacific Gas & Electric Co.
California Court of Appeal
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Butte County and from an order refusing a new trial. John C. Gray, Judge. The facts are stated in the opinion of the court.
1Opinion
In his petition for rehearing plaintiff urges as ground therefor that, in the opinion heretofore rendered, the court invaded the province of the jury in dealing with the facts concerning the defendant, Pacific Gas Electric Company. The petition states: "The court may possibly be right in its view of the evidence as indicated in its statement of facts, which on the basis of lack of control of the electrical company, and complete control by the mining company, would exempt the electrical company from liability and hold the mining company liable. But where did the court get its right to usurp…
2Cases cited2 opinions
- Terrace Water Co. v. San Antonio Light & Power Co.California Court of Appeal · 1905
- Augusta Railway & Electric Co. v. BeaglesCourt of Appeals of Georgia · 1913