Legal Opinion

People ex rel. Smith v. Judge of the Wayne Circuit Court

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided April 16, 1873PublishedCited by 1 opinion

Application for mandamus. The relator brought suit in the Wayne circuit against Zina Lloyd, by summons in a plea of “trespass on the Case,” which was duly served. He afterwards declared in an action for breach of covenant.

Read the full summary

Application for mandamus. The relator brought suit in the Wayne circuit against Zina Lloyd, by summons in a plea of “trespass on the Case,” which was duly served. He afterwards declared in an action for breach of covenant. Defendant's counsel moved to set aside this declaration, on account of its variance from the summons in respect to the form of action, which motion the respondent granted, after full argument, and an order was entered in said cause setting aside the declaration and striking it from the files. The only ground upon which this order was granted was the variance aforesaid. The…

1Opinion of the Court

The court

held that á declaration could not be set' aside for variance from the writ; such variance in non-bailable actions is entirely immaterial; and even in bailable actions it would operate only to discharge the bail and not to render the declaration a nullity.

Mandamus granted.

2Cited by1 opinion

  1. Longyear v. Minnesota Lumber Co.Michigan Supreme Court · 1896

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API