Buckler v. Johnson County Sheriff's Department

I must respectfully dissent.

For the most part, the majority opinion tracks the evidence disclosed on the record. However, the majority opinion leaves out what I consider to be some crucial facts.

It was established by another witness that petitioner was obviously intoxicated at the time of the alleged offense. In addition, another female student advised police officers that petitioner continuously refused to disclose his address to the complainant or anyone else. In fact, an attempt was made by complainant, without success, to determine petitioner’s address from persons at one of the local…