Legal Opinion · Concurrence

Snyder v. Utah Construction Co.

Idaho Supreme Court

Decided October 23, 1934No. 6173Published

1Concurrence

MORGAN, J.,

Concurring. — The conclusion that the appeal must be dismissed is correct, but I am not ready to decide that an order granting a motion to vacate a judgment and for judgment notwithstanding the verdict is not appeal-able, for it is not clear to my mind that it is not a special order made after final judgment within the meaning of I. C. A., section 11-201. Our court has not heretofore passed on this question. Such a motion resembles one made to procure an order setting aside a judgment, and we have held orders disposing of such motions to be appealable. (Oliver v. Kootenai County,…

2Cases cited4 opinions

  1. Central Deep Creek Orchard Co. v. C. C. Taft Co.Idaho Supreme Court · 1921
  2. Shumake v. ShumakeIdaho Supreme Court · 1910
  3. Oliver v. Kootenai CountyIdaho Supreme Court · 1907
  4. Duffield v. OhneweinIdaho Supreme Court · 1920

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API