Venture Encoding Service, Inc. v. Atlantic Mutual Insurance Co.

*738JOHN CAYCE,

Chief Justice, dissenting.

I dissent to the court’s opinion denying appellee’s motion for rehearing. I would grant the motion and affirm the trial court’s summary judgment because Exclusion “1” of the printer’s E & 0 form specifically excludes from coverage replacement costs due to the insured’s faulty workmanship.

The clear and unambiguous intent of Exclusion “1” is to preclude from coverage replacement costs incurred by Venture Encoding Service Inc.’s faulty workmanship. This type of “business risk” exclusion is common in liability policies, the purpose of which is to “provide…