Rogers v. Grewal

Consistent with this guidance, many jurists have concluded that text, history, and tradition are dispositive in determining whether a challenged law violates the right to keep and bear arms. See, e.g. , Mance v. Sessions , 896 F.3d 390 , 394 (C.A.5 2018) (Elrod, J., joined by Jones, Smith, Willett, Ho, Duncan, and Engelhardt, JJ., dissenting from denial of reh'g en banc); Tyler v. Hillsdale Cty. Sheriff's Dept. , 837 F.3d 678 , 702-703 (C.A.6 2016) (Batchelder, J., concurring in most of judgment); Gowder v. Chicago , 923 F.Supp.2d 1110 , 1123 (N.D. Ill. 2012) ; Heller v. District of Columbia…