Garraghty v. French

By Judge Beverly W. Snukals

This case came before the Court for a bench trial on February 27,2009. By an Order entered December 10, 2008, Plaintiffs’ suit was limited to a Request to Quiet Title. Evidence was presented, and argument was heard. The Court finds that Plaintiffs are not entitled to quiet title because, even if there is a cloud on the title, Plaintiffs did not properly invoke the right of first refusal agreement such that the Court could find that Defendant declined to exercise his rights.

Plaintiffs David Garraghty and Martha Tingle were the owners of properties located at…