Board of Directors v. McGuire

MEMORANDUM OPINION

The plaintiff, the Board of Directors of Shibui (hereinafter Shibui), a condominium association, seeks a judgment in the amount of $2,023.26 for common charges assessed against the defendants Thomas R. McGuire and Geraldine Carr,1 and has asked this court to dismiss defendant Carr’s counterclaim for failing to state a claim.2 Plaintiff asserts that even if all of the factual allegations of Ms. Carr’s counterclaim are true she still is not entitled to any relief.

The court understands Shibui to be advancing three related arguments in support of its motion. First, Shibui…