Freddy Curiel v. Amy Miller

I concur fully in Judge Murguia’s opinion for the court. I also agree generally with Judge Bybee that our decision-making would be aided significantly if the California Supreme Court were to explain more clearly the basis for its summary denials. Even more important, I would urge the California Supreme Court to specify in its opinions whether it is deciding on the merits any or all of the questions of federal constitutional law that are raised in the case before it, and identify the constitutional basis of all such claims that it is denying, if any.

I write separately, however, to urge the…