Robinson v. Robinson

Dissenting Opinion by

Rhodes, P. J.:

I am unable to agree with the majority opinion that plaintiff, John H. Robinson, is entitled to a divorce on the present record. The majority suggests that this is a case where a younger woman married an older man for his money and property alone without giving anything in return therefor. Even if true, it would not afford a legal basis for severing the marital tie. As I view it, the matter is in fact much more complex. Therefore I file this dissent.

The master and the lower court considered credibility the determinative issue, as in most respects the *580testimon…