John Thallon & Co. v. Edsil Trading Corp.

302 N.Y. 390 (1951)

John Thallon & Co. Inc., Respondent,

v.

Edsil Trading Corp., Appellant.

Court of Appeals of the State of New York.

Argued January 3, 1951.

Decided April 12, 1951

Bruce Bromley, Bertram Sommer and Maurice Rosenberg for appellant.

Myron Kommel for respondent.

CONWAY, DYE and FROESSEL, JJ., concur in opinion by DESMOND, J.; CONWAY, DESMOND and DYE, JJ., concur in separate opinion by FROESSEL, J.; FULD, J., dissents and votes for reversal and dismissal of the complaint in an opinion in which LOUGHRAN, Ch. J., and LEWIS, J., concur.

DESMOND, J.

The question here is: did acceptance and…