Millage v. Churchill
Supreme Court of Colorado
Action to quiet title. Judgment for plaintiff. Error to the District Court of Phillips County, Hon. II. P. Burke, Judge.
1DissentJustice Denison
I cannot agree with the majority opinion.
First, — It was error to reject the testimony of Carl Millage. There was nothing in his testimony that did not show the circumstances under which the deed in question was prepared and executed. It is true of all contracts that they not only may but ought to be construed in the light of the circumstances of their execution, — and to that end oral testimony is always competent. Killgore v. Cranmer, 35 Colo. 485, 487, 84 Pac. 70; Messenger v. German American Ins. Co., 47 Colo. 448, 453, 107 Pac. 643. I agree that it was right to exclude testimony as to…
2Cases cited4 opinions
- County Commissioners v. City of Colorado SpringsSupreme Court of Colorado · 1919
- Johnson v. BardenSupreme Court of Vermont · 1912
- Messenger v. German American InsuranceSupreme Court of Colorado · 1910
- Killgore v. CranmerSupreme Court of Colorado · 1906