Legal Opinion · Dissent

Payne v. Ohio Performance Acad., Inc.

Ohio Court of Appeals

Decided September 29, 2017No. 17AP-202Published

1DissentBrunner, J.

{¶ 33} I respectfully dissent from the opinion of the majority, because in my view reliance on Simpson v. Big Bear Stores Co. , 73 Ohio St.3d 130 , 652 N.E.2d 702 (1995), does not sufficiently square with the facts presented. The subsequent appellate cases citing Simpson , whether they follow or distinguish Simpson , thus far have largely applied Simpson in connection with criminal assaults of patrons on commercial property-not close enough to the facts in Payne's situation of falling off a stage. Moreover, the focus on control and by whom-VV Venue, LLC ("VV Venue"), Ohio Performance Academy,…

2Cases cited12 opinions

  1. Armstrong v. Best Buy Co.Ohio Supreme Court · 2003
  2. Alexander v. Buckeye Pipe Line Co.Ohio Supreme Court · 1978
  3. O'Day v. WebbOhio Supreme Court · 1972
  4. Mergenthal v. Star Banc Corp.Ohio Court of Appeals · 1997
  5. Simpson v. Big Bear Stores Co.Ohio Supreme Court · 1995

7 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API