Ricoh Co., Ltd. v. Quanta Computer Inc.

GAJARSA, Circuit Judge,

dissenting as to Section III.B.

I agree with my colleagues with respect to the result and judgment reached, but I must dissent as to that portion of the opinion 'and judgment at Section III.B. Specifically, I disagree with my colleagues’ decision to decide the difficult issue of contributory infringement on the basis of policy concerns without due regard for the text of 35 U.S.C. § 271(c) and am of the opinion that the majority makes three errors in its analysis. First, the majority ignores the fact that Quanta does not sell or offer to sell the accused components, as…