Ragbir v. Homan

Judge Walker dissents in a separate opinion.

Droney, Circuit Judge:

*57The principal question presented in this appeal is whether Ravidath Ragbir, an alien subject to a valid final order of removal, has presented a legally recognizable claim to enjoin the Government from deporting him on the basis of his public speech that was critical of the Government's immigration policies and practices. Related to that question is whether Congress has deprived courts of jurisdiction to hear Ragbir's claim,1 and if so, whether the Suspension Clause of the Constitution, U.S. Const. art. I, § 9, cl. 2,…