Craig v. O'Rear

Dissenting Opinion by

Judge Mookman.

I concur in the statements of the opinion that a legislative act should not be declared invalid until every doubt has- been resolved in its favor, and that the propriety, wisdom or expe'dieney of legislation is not a matter to be considered in measuring it by constitutional limitations and requirements. Nevertheless I am convinced that the act in question violates sections 27, -28 and 29 of the state Constitution, and I deem it appropriate that I state the reasons that impel that conviction.

It is undoubtedly true, and indeed seems to be conceded in the…