Coulthard v. Cossairt

*94URBIGKIT, Chief Justice,

specially concurring.

I concur, but write further in analysis that the proven injury in this case reasonably justified the damage award and we need not apply an extreme test for what was fairly and reasonably determined by jury verdict. Specifically, I question our continued lack of judicial responsibility in jury supervision encompassed within characterizations of “shock[ing] the judicial conscience”, “an irresistible inference that passion, prejudice or other improper cause had invaded the trial[ ]” or “so excessive as to strike mankind, at the first blush, as being…