Matter of Bogart (Commr. of Labor)

We respectfully dissent. Given the restrictions that LaValle Transportation, Inc. placed upon claimant in this case and this Court’s recent affirmances in two cases involving similar restrictions (see Matter of Harold [Leonard’s Transp. — Commissioner of Labor], 133 AD3d 1069 [2015], lv dismissed 26 NY3d 1136 [2016]; Matter of Wilder [RB Humphreys Inc. — Commissioner of Labor], 133 AD3d 1073 [2015]), we disagree with the majority’s reversal of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board’s decisions regarding claimant. Here, as to claimant, the indicia of control retained by LaValle are numerous…