Moffett v. Bozeman Canning Co.

Mr. Justice Anderson:

I dissent from that portion of the the opinion of the court wherein it is held that the circumstantial evidence adduced on the hearing is sufficient to sustain the judgment of the trial court. I concur in the statements in the opinion holding that the so-called opinions of the doctors are too speculative and conjectural to form the basis of findings.

If, under the facts in this case, owing to the lack of knowledge, the opinions of the doctors to whom the essential facts were submitted in hypothetical questions are unworthy of consideration, how can a court draw a…