Grogan v. Hiram Walker & Sons, Ltd.

Mr. Justice McKenna,

with whom concurred

Mr. Justice Day and Mr. Justice Clarke, dissenting.'

I am unable to concur in the opinion and judgment of the court.

*91The first case presents the right to transport intoxicating liquor in bond through the United States in accordance with certain rights given by the Revised Statutes and a treaty with Great Britain, notwithstanding the Eighteenth Amendment of the Constitution and its auxiliary legislation, the Volstead Act.

The second case concerns the transshipment of like liquor from one British ship to another British ship in New York harbor. In the first…