Robert Cahaly v. Paul LaRosa, III

Affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded with instructions by published opinion. Judge DIAZ wrote the opinion, in which Judge WYNN and Judge THACKER joined.

DIAZ, Circuit Judge:

Robert C. Cahaly, a self-described Republican political consultant, was arrested for alleged violations of South Carolina’s anti-robocall statute. After the charges were dismissed, Cahaly filed suit, challenging the statute on three First Amendment grounds: as an unlawful regulation of speech, as impermissibly compelling speech, and as unconstitutionally vague. Cahaly also sought damages from the law enforcement…