Cicardo v. Mangual

ZULICK, J.,

This case comes before the court on defendants Shawn Bates and Kyle Garrity’s motions for summary judgment. Plaintiff filed complaints on February 6,2013 at No. 11522 Civil 2010, and on July 2, 2014 at No. 07668 Civil 2010. Plaintiff alleges that Jacqueline Tara Cicardo, a minor, was injured in a collision while riding in a vehicle driven by Jonathan Mangual, now deceased. Jonathan Mangual was intoxicated after attending two house parties. Plaintiff further alleges that *256both Shawn Bates and Kyle Garrity, minors at the time, are liable to Ms. Cicardo as social hosts for furnishing…