Foucha v. Louisiana

The Louisiana statutory scheme the Court strikes down today is not some quirky relic of a bygone age, but a codification of the current provisions of the American Law Institute’s Model Penal Code. Invalidating this quite reasonable scheme is bad enough; even worse is the Court’s failure to explain precisely what is wrong with it. In parts of its opinion, the Court suggests that the scheme is unconstitutional because it provides for the continued confinement of insanity acquittees who, although still dangerous, have “recovered” their sanity. Ante, at 77 (“[T]he committed acquittee is entitled…