Warren v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Co.

CONERY,. J.,

concurs in part, dissents in part,- and assigns reasons.

hi respectfully dissent from the majority’s decision to affirm the trial court’s ruling to grant a new trial from the first jury verdict' in favor ’ of Teleflex. I would re-vérse'and render-judgment in favor of Teleflex, dismissing all of plaintiffs claims with prejudicé at his cost. This decision renders moot all remaining assignments of error. There are three separate appeals consolidated and considered together. I will discuss' only the appeal in docket number 15-1113 alleging trial court error by granting a new trial from…