Seneca Insurance v. Certified Moving & Storage Co.

This action arose out of plaintiffs claim that it was entitled to recover premiums due under a commercial general liability insurance policy issued to defendants. We reject plaintiffs argument that the documentary evidence, including the affidavits of its senior officers explaining the methodology used in calculating premiums, and all of the applicable Insurance Services Office (ISO) rules adopted by plaintiff regarding premium *678computation, as well as its filed rates, was sufficient to make out a prima facie showing of entitlement to judgment as a matter of law (see Commissioners of State…