Smith & Smith, Inc. v. South Carolina Public Service Commission

(dissenting) :

I respectfully dissent and would reverse the order of the circuit court.

*409To warrant a reversal of the Commission’s actions this court must find that the plaintiffs have been denied a right granted to them by either:(1) a rule of the Public Service Commission,(2) a statute enacted by the General Assembly, or(3) a state or federal constitutional mandate.

The plaintiffs have not contended that they are entitled to an adversary-type trial or hearing by reason of any rule of the Commission or by reason of any statute. A search of the rules and of the statutes indicates that the…