David F. Miller v. Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance Co.

OPINION

Justice FLAHERTY,

for the Court.

This opinion addresses three appeals that have arisen from a labyrinth of litigation brought by the plaintiffs, David F. Miller and Miller’s Auto Body, Inc. (MAB), against the defendants, Arnica Mutual Insurance Company, Arnica Property and Casualty Insurance Company (collectively Arnica), Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance Company (Metropolitan), and Allstate Insurance Company, Inc. (Allstate). 1 All three appeals were argued before the Supreme Court on December 3, 2014. After hearing the arguments and examining the memoranda filed by the…