City of Chicago v. Farwell

"Mr. Justice Carter,

dissenting:

I do not concur in the conclusions reached on several questions decided in the foregoing opinion. I am not in accord with the finding of the opinion that the date of the filing of the commissioners’ report in the county court must be fixed as the date of valuing the property condemned. The commissioners’ report was filed July 15, 1915. The trial as to this property began October 2, 1917, and a judgment on the whole case was entered March 8, 1918. Counsel for appellant offered to prove on the trial that its machinery had advanced in market value between the date…