Lyman v. Perlmutter

Pee Cubiam.

We have been addressed by an argument which asks us to overrule the decisions of the Supreme Court in the first and fourth Departments. (Lyman v. Rochester Title Ins. Co., 37 App. Div. 234; Lyman v. Brucker, 26 Misc. 594; affirmed on appeal, 42 App. Div. 624; Lyman v. Shenandoah Social Club), 39 App. Div. 459.) The argument, of the learned counsel for the appellant in support of his contention is forcible and able, but all of the views therein taken seem to have been met and answered by the decisions already rendered; and if we were doubtful of the correctness of such answer, its…