Legal Opinion · Dissent

Minter v. McSwain

Supreme Court of South Carolina

Decided November 14, 1923No. 11337Published

1Dissent

Mr. Justice Coti-iran,

(dissenting) : While the license issued by the Commissioner does not amount to a recommendation of the stock, it certainly is an assurance that the Commissioner has at least exercised ordinary care in performing the duties imposed upon him by the statute. It is held in the case of Williams v. Oil Co., 127 S. C., 430; 121 S. E., 363, that under circumstances precautions in addition to those required by law may be demanded. I think that the complaint presented issues for a jury.

2Cases cited1 opinion

  1. Williams v. Standard Oil Co.Supreme Court of South Carolina · 1924