Harrison v. Civil Service Commission

Schaefer, C.J., and Hershey, J.,

dissenting:

We agree with the holding of the court that the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers is hot violated when the findings of an administrative agency are reviewed under the Administrative Review Act to determine whether they are contrary to the manifest weight of evidence.^ VV"e agree also with the holding of the court, that the statute makes conclusive upon us the findings of fact of the Appellate Court, and that unless we can say either that the evidence on which that court relied, taken with all its favorable intendments, was not…