Clulee v. Giambelluca

1U agree with the majority insofar as the majority affirms that portion of the judgment denying Bayou Fleet Partnership’s *222request that it be granted a right of access across the plaintiffs’ property. However, I respectfully dissent from that part of the opinion which affirms the portion of the trial court judgment dismissing Bayou Fleet Partnership’s intervention. In my view, the majority errs in affirming the judgment in its entirety.

The majority views the 1999 partition as determinative of the ownership of the disputed tract. The majority concludes that the Clulees, by that judgment,…