Alford Timber Inc. v. Caulkins

In these consolidated cases the appellant challenges three separate orders addressing an issue of liability insurance coverage as between two policies, and by which it was determined that both policies provide primary coverage. We conclude that a proper construction of the policies yields the primary coverage under the appellee Transportation Casualty policy only, with the appellant’s policy providing excess coverage.

Civil actions were filed below in connection with an automobile accident involving a tractor-trailer, with allegations of resulting damage to other vehicles, individuals, and…