LaBorde v. Shelter Mutual Insurance

I find no abuse of discretion in the trial court’s ruling granting the motion in li-mine. I find that the accuracy of the event data recorder printout is questionable for the following reasons. The event data recorder was removed from the Mills vehicle two weeks after the accident. The vehicle was not secured in a police impound yard, but was stored by a towing business following the accident. The officer who removed the event data recorder from the vehicle had no training on how to properly remove the recorder. The Defendants’ expert testified that the vehicle should have been photographed,…